partiallydisassembled.net

My Favourite Album

2006-12-04 12:32:05

In response to Rachel's post on last night's show: I didn't have a problem with its sound, maybe there is a problem with your TV? Most of the "joke" segments fell very, very flat, the exceptions being the Radiohead and Chilli Peppers bits, and the "comedians" were awful--no interest in music and their scripted banter was just irritating. But I liked Dicko's and Kram's (I've had drinks with Kram because I know someone who knows someone who's going out with him!) opinions. The results, though, were unbelievably good. Far from what record stores, movies, TV shows and in particular, Australian Idol, would have us believe, the unanimous voice of Australians prefer intelligent rock music to manufactured pop. Well, ABC viewers. Music made by bands instead of pitch-correction software. The record companies could be cleaning up (just look at the chart figures for those top 10 albums) by sponsoring original, interesting music and taking dives with unsuccessful bands once in a while. Why shouldn't the list be dominated by concept albums (and I don't think it is: only Dark Side and Sgt Pepper's, by my count)? Of course we're going to prefer listening to an album that has a coherent structure and narrative over one which is "the songs we recorded in the last year, in no particular order." For you to assert that there is white male dominance in the results requires that you provide some alternatives. OK, Michael Jackson should've been on the list, who else? There are plenty of outstanding female and non-white performers, but not that many popular ones. This is not an issue with the voters, but with the producers (or the marketers, or just the music). The fact that some of these incredibly intelligent musicians are dead now is tragic, but has no bearing on the music. And in what way is Mozart's death at a young age, before he peaked, in any way "good"? Men prefer listening to male musicians? Don't make me laugh. Who listens to Anthony Callea, Jeff Buckley, Van Morrison? I couldn't find a source on demographics, but can you?

cobungra writes:

ALBUM - only a couple of these were atually albums in the sense of narrative and coherence. There should have been a test before people were allowed to vote. Where's Bob Dylan ? Yep the humour was non existent and it's apalling that the panel hadn't bothered to think it over before going on. I agree with Rachel, the editing was clumsy, overall production of the show poor. Women and non anglos are unrepresented in pop, how the hell do they get to compete when no one records them? The producers fo the show could have made something seriously interesting and more fun.

Rachel writes:

Intelligent rock music? Oh, come ON! I'd give that to 1, 4, 5 and maaaybe 10 if I was in a good mood. The other's might be exciting, clever, emotional, but there're not frickin' intelligent. Bat out of Hell was the other concept album. (For "concept" here, please read "unbearable") No, I couldnt' find any sources on demographics, which is why I think it's unfortunate that the ABC didn't collect the data of those who voted. And for those people who misread the rules it was called My _Favourite_ Album. Not the "The Best Produced Album Evah", the "Album Best Defined as All Killer, No Filler" or the "Album in Your Collection That's Only There To Impress Your Friends" But I agree with Cobungra - producers don't release "albums" by women, they release singles. There's probably some intricate marketing formula that reveals that women are more likely to buy single pieces of music, whereas men want a whole (emotion substitute?) experience. Which in turn might go back to men having time to listen to entire albums and appreciate the intricacies of thier construction, whereas women only have the luxury to take their entertainment in 3.5 minute bites. Perhaps a search for Autralia's Favourite Song, or Australia's Favourite Musician would be more enlightening. It would certainly give artists like Kate Bush, Madonna, Bjork, a better chance of appearing. Who listens to Anthony Callea, Jeff Buckley, Van Morrison? The tone deaf and the boring. I forgot you were so defensive about music, jeez, can't even take a Mozart joke...

Alex writes:

Right, album is just a unit of purchase. Some albums have narratives, making them more favourable, others don't, but are favourable anyway. The question was indeed what your favourite album is, something that's unlikely to get much consensus as favouritism is influenced by all manner of personal experiences. 0/2 people reading this blog would have even heard of my favourite album. The top 100 in this list are not the top 100 favourite albums of Australians--they are the top 100 *first preference* favourite albums. Everyone likes Dylan and Bjork (together at last!), but a great many more people choose to listen to Radiohead first. A preferential or ranking voting system could have gotten these guys much higher (maybe Blood on the Tracks is everybody's second favourite album). I think the appearance of Jeff Buckley and Meat Loaf showed that this was not an "album to impress my friends" contest. Pink Floyd? Maybe. I just assumed it was Cobungra who voted that to the top. "The producers fo the show could have made something seriously interesting and more fun."--yeah, they could've made another episode of Firefly. But for a tally on this question (*not* the question you might've wanted them to ask), the results are really good. Should we only ask questions that allow women to win? That would bias the results even more, since you're engineering the answer! There are some figures here that show women to be bigger users of online music stores, which would indicate a preference for single songs over entire albums. Even if it is the case that men listen to albums more than women (whoops, that came out wrong!), I fail to see the connection to how many favourite albums include female artists. It's nonsense to assert that men listen to men and women listen to women.

Cobungra writes:

Hey if I was voting Pink Floyd to the top it would have been an album they did 15 years before DSOTM. hmmph ..but you raise an interesting question "..only ask questions that allow women to win?" At the edge of that is asking questions that make certain that they won't. I admit it, "album" means anything you want it to mean. Used to mean a boxed set of vinyl records..

Creative, sort of.

2006-11-30 00:55:03

Learning Wings3D, came up with a thing. One spot and one point light, 2x1024x1024 shadow map, 4x800x600 buffer, rendered in Yafray in 6 minutes.

jonathan hartley writes:

But where is it now? :-)

Richard writes:

That's cool ;)

ReST + XSLT + LaTeX: attack of the mixed case

2006-11-28 18:08:05

Have been writing some course material for next year's graphics subjects. I think my content creation workflow is pretty nifty. Each document is a separate ReST file (I prefer to work like that rather than on one large file). The rst2html.py writer doesn't support combining files (for the purposes of generating a ToC, for example), so I had to write my own XSLT stylesheet to transform ReST XML into XHTML. This is also helpful because it's far easier to customise this stylesheet than the docwriter. The ToC is defined in a separate XML file giving names and URIs of each item, and read in by the XSLT stylesheet using the document() function. xsltproc doesn't support this yet, so I'm using saxon, which is kinda slow. The stylesheet is able to do some clever working-out of where the current document is in relation to the ToC, so only the ancestor and child sections are shown expanded (cheap, Javascript-free hierarchical menu). I define a new interpreted role called "math-tex" which allows me to embed LaTeX equations into the ReST document. The XSLT stylesheet writes these equations to separate files (another 2.0 feature not supported by xsltproc), and a separate Makefile takes care of converting these to PNGs for inclusion into the XHTML. Downsides: * Running "make" can take up to a minute for thirty or so reasonably short files, thanks to the complex XSLT involved. * Backslashes in LaTeX equations need to be escaped, for example: :math:tex:'1\\\\over 3'. Although you can specialise the "literal" role, it seems you can't take advantage of its escape processing. * Make requires two passes after a new equation is added, since it doesn't know about the generated files until it expands wildcards again. Upsides: * Very little source upkeep: ReST is doing everything I need it to do now, and the XSLT/XML contents takes care of maintaining links. * Time to make coffee while compiling.

Brain train

2006-11-23 12:22:08

I often compose blog entries in my head while I'm away from the computer: while cooking, showering, walking, etc. Yesterday I was on a dawdling stopping-all-stations train to the city. Something I saw out the window got me thinking about something very important to me, that was very witty, and I spent most of the trip working out what to write. I even came up with a clever title. Well, it's completely forgotten now. Stupid REM sleep: faulty GC.

pyglet: image

2006-11-17 23:26:25

Pyglet now has some pretty decent image loading, using QuickTime on OS X, GDI+ on Windows XP and Gdk on Linux. There's also fallbacks for using PIL and a Python PNG loader (which is slow but is always going to work). The range of supported image types varies according to platform, the lowest common denominator seems to include BMP, PNG, JPEG, TIF and GIF. QuickTime wins on the format count, which includes PDF loading. Still some niceties with errors to work out, and more testing of different file types and their variants. I'll see how much support these libraries have for saving images in addition to loading.
login